Trump Cleaned Up 5G – WSJ


dado ruvic/Reuters

One of the Trump administration’s major foreign policy initiatives has gone largely unnoticed. You probably heard that the president left the Paris climate accords and Iran nuclear deal, launched a trade war, ordered the killing of Iran’s

Gen. Qassem Solemaini,

moved a U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, and presided over peace agreements between Israel and several former Arab enemies. But you may have missed the Clean Network initiative.

In early 2020, Secretary of State

Mike Pompeo

urged friends and allies not to include any high-risk (read: Chinese) vendors in their 5G networks. Many countries, including the U.K., had already decided to use Huawei over rivals




In February, senior Huawei executive

Ryan Ding

announced that the company had secured 91 5G commercial contracts, 47 of them in Europe. The Clean Network plan seemed doomed to fail.

Then Covid-19 struck. The Chinese obfuscated the virus’s origins and attempted to sow division in the West by supplying personal protective equipment to some but not to others. Western governments began to see Beijing in a different light.

Keith Krach,

undersecretary for economic growth, energy and the environment, began pleading with friendly countries to ditch their Chinese plans. He found allies among congressional Democrats. “Nations cannot cede our telecommunication infrastructure to China for financial expediency,” Speaker

Nancy Pelosi

told a conference in February. A couple of weeks later, a bipartisan group of senators led by

Chuck Schumer


Ben Sasse

urged the U.K. to reverse its 5G decision.

At the end of 2020, the global 5G situation looked radically different than it had at the start of the year. Britain had reversed course, banning Huawei from its 5G network. The Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Greece, Latvia, Poland, Romania and Sweden all opted not to use Chinese suppliers. The Italian government, long a top target of Chinese charm offensives, had banned a top telecom firm from using Huawei. And last month Germany, often considered soft on China, passed a law that allows the government to block telecom firms’ deals with Huawei on national security grounds. Global telecom firms from

READ  Is this a good time to buy Bitcoin? Russia cryptocurrency price rumours




have joined Clean Network too, vowing not to use Chinese components.

The Clean Network initiative has become an undisputed success for an administration that was often met with international scorn. And it looks likely to stick. Neither President-elect

Joe Biden

nor foreign leaders appear interested in reversing it. Infrastructure isn’t like a treaty, which a country can simply leave. Installing a 5G network requires a massive up front investment. Nobody will want to tear it up and rebuild.

Until now the 5G market has consisted mostly of Huawei, Ericsson and Nokia. But with Huawei and other Chinese firms excluded from 5G, and possibly 6G in several years’ time, there will be a niche—indeed, a need—for new market players. We’re likely to see a flourishing of innovation and business activity.

Though its success has been a quiet one, Clean Network could turn out to be the Trump administration’s most enduring foreign-policy legacy.

Ms. Braw is a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8


Leave a Reply

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.